Copyright© 2025. All Rights Reserved by EuroAmerican Education.
Honorary Doctorate vs PhD
The terms “Honorary Doctorate” and “PhD” often make students curious and confused, as they both are associated with the same title of “Doctor”. Moreover, they show fundamentally different purposes, pathways, and achievements. When a PhD is an earned and research-based academic degree which requires dedicated research and study, on the other hand, an honorary degree is a ceremonial recognition facilitating a person's exceptional contribution in a specific field or society or to culture. Through this article, we will look at the differences between these two distinct degrees, their achievements, their origin, prerequisites, significance and societal perceptions, and also address common misconceptions.
Universities provide their highest academic degree to students through Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) programmes in most academic fields. The degree stands for advanced knowledge and original research and major contributions to academic understanding. Students require 3-5 years to complete a PhD, respective to their academic field and national standards and their personal development timeline.
PhD candidates need to obtain the following requirements to achieve their degree.
Complete Advanced Coursework: PhD students undertake specialised courses to deepen their understanding of the field.
Conduct Original Research: The dissertation serves as the fundamental requirement for a PhD because it requires students to perform extensive research that produces original knowledge for their academic field. The process demands students develop research questions and conduct experiments or analyses, which they must then defend before a panel of expert reviewers.
Pass Comprehensive Examination: Many programmes require qualifying exams to test candidates' mastery of their subject.
Publish or Present Research: PhD candidates are often expected to publish their work in peer-reviewed journals or present at academic conferences.
Defend the Dissertation: The last stage requires candidates to defend their work in front of faculty members who will ask them questions about their research findings.
The PhD journey is demanding, often requiring full-time dedication. In the United States, for example, the average time to complete a PhD is around 3-5 years, according to a 2020 report by the National Science Foundation. In disciplines like humanities, this can extend to 7-9 years, while STEM fields may take slightly less time. Candidates often face financial challenges, balancing teaching or research assistantships with their studies.
A PhD signifies expertise and the ability to conduct independent research. The academic qualification serves as a fundamental requirement for various educational and research-based professions, which include becoming a university professor and leading scientific organisations. The degree holds worldwide recognition, which makes it important for academic institutions, industrial organisations and policy development. PhD holders function as intellectual leaders who generate innovative knowledge within their academic fields of study.
An honorary doctorate, known as "honoris causa" in Latin, represents a degree which universities and institutions bestow upon individuals who have made significant contributions to society and culture and their particular domain of expertise. Unlike a PhD, it is not earned through academic study or research but is conferred as a gesture of esteem.
Read Also: Top Celebrities and World Leaders Who Have Received Honorary Doctorate
Honorary doctorates receive their awards through these criteria:
Exceptional Achievements: Recipients are typically individuals who have made significant impacts in areas such as arts, science, philanthropy, public service, or business. For example, Nobel laureates, influential artists, or humanitarian leaders are common recipients.
Alignment with Institutional Values: Universities often select individuals whose work aligns with their mission or values. For instance, a university focused on social justice might honour a civil rights activist.
Nomination and Selection: The process varies by institution but generally involves nominations from faculty, alumni, or external stakeholders, followed by approvals from a university committee or board.
Honorary doctorates generally are given out during graduation ceremonies, and at such events, the recipients give speeches or are honoured with the graduates. This type of degree does not require any academic work, attendance, or a thesis. Recipients are provided with a diploma and granted the privilege, which is subject to certain conditions related to geography and the granting institution, to be referred to as "Dr".
Oprah Winfrey is a notable single recipient of the honorary doctorate. She was awarded in 2013 by Harvard University in recognition of her media and philanthropic work. Malala Yousafzai, awarded by numerous institutions, is another great example of a globally known figure. Malala is recognised for fighting for the education of children, especially girls. These honorary doctorates showcase the wide range of impactful work, from media to global activism, that is brought into appreciation.
While both confer the title of "Doctor", the differences between a PhD and an honorary doctorate are stark. Below is a detailed comparison across several dimensions:
PhD: The goal is to educate and train researchers to contribute scholarly innovations through original research. It is an academic degree earned through intellectual effort.
Honorary Doctorate: The goal is to recognise notable contributions to society. It is a symbolic recognition and is not academically earned.
PhD: Is a structured and merit-based process that involves years of study, coursework, research, and the completion of a dissertation.
Honorary Doctorate: Does not require any academic work. It is bestowed based on achievements and reputation, sometimes without the recipient's prior knowledge.
PhD: Takes several years, often involving significant personal and financial investment.
Honorary Doctorate: Involves no time commitment from the recipient, as it is a one-time conferral.
PhD: Prestigious within academic and professional circles, as it reflects proven expertise and dedication.
Honorary Doctorate: Prestigious in a societal context, as it recognises exceptional contributions, but it lacks the academic rigour associated with a PhD.
PhD: Recognised as a formal qualification for academic and professional roles, such as teaching at universities or leading research projects.
Honorary Doctorate: Not a qualification for an academic or professional purpose. Recipients are generally refrained from using the title "Dr" in academic settings to avoid confusion with earned degrees.
PhD: Standardised globally, with similar requirements across countries, though specific processes may vary (e.g., the viva voce in the UK vs. dissertation defence in the US).
Honorary Doctorate: Practices vary widely. In some countries, like the US, honorary doctorates are common and highly ceremonial, while in others, they are rare.
A common misunderstanding is that an honorary doctorate carries the same academic weight as a PhD. This is not true. While both confer the title "Doctor", a PhD represents years of scholarly work, whereas an honorary doctorate degree does not confer academic credentials.
In many cases, honorary doctorate recipients are being told to use the title sparingly or only in connection with the awarding institution. For example, although Oprah Winfrey may be referred to as "Dr Winfrey" at Harvard events, using the title in academic or professional settings might be misleading to others. On the other hand, PhD holders use the title "Dr" as a standard professional designation.
While honorary doctorates require no academic work, they are not easily obtained. Universities carefully select recipients based on extraordinary achievements, and the process involves rigorous vetting. Only a small number of individuals receive such honour annually.
Both PhDs and honorary doctorates play important roles in society, albeit in different ways. PhDs drive innovations and knowledge creation, shaping industries, policies, and education. Honorary doctorates, meanwhile, celebrate individuals who inspire or transform society and reinforce the value of diverse contributions. For example, when Nelson Mandela received an honorary doctorate from the University of Stellenbosch in 1996, it symbolised recognition of his global impact on peace and reconciliation.
However, the conferral of an honorary doctorate can sometimes spark controversy. Critics argue that universities may award them for publicity or to align with influential figures, potentially diluting their significance. For example, in the year 2019, Taylor Swift receiving an honorary doctorate award from New York University got mixed reviews from the public; while some praised her for the achievement, others questioned the academic merit of the award.
The question regarding the prestige of the degree depends on the context. If we are considering the academic and research setting, a PhD without a doubt holds more prestige because of its rigorous requirements and contribution to the field. But if we are talking about societal or cultural context, an honorary doctorate holds immense prestige, as it usually recognises the globally recognised celebs and people. Ultimately, the two serve different purposes and are not directly comparable.
The difference between an honorary doctorate and a PhD lies in their purpose, attainment process, and societal roles. A PhD is an earned academic degree that signifies expertise and original research, requiring years of dedication. On the other hand, an honorary doctorate is a prestigious recognition of exceptional contribution and doesn't need any academic backing. Both are valuable in their own place, but they cater to different spheres of achievement. Understanding these differences can help you in clarifying their significance and also ensure appropriate recognition and contribution to academics and society.
Read Also: Doctorate in Business Administration by London School of Management and Technology
Read Also: Doctorate in Business Administration by Birchwood University
Read Also: Doctorate in Business Administration by EIMT
